'I suspect the job was too difficult' - Cosgrove on MacLean

  • Published

Broadcaster and St Johnstone fan Stuart Cosgrove believes that the manager's job at McDiarmid Park was "too difficult" for Steven MacLean, and called for the club to now appoint an experienced manager.

MacLean was sacked after a 4-0 defeat to St Mirren left St Johnstone five points adrift at the bottom of the Scottish Premiership, having replaced Callum Davidson towards the end of last season.

“One of the things by employing Steven MacLean was that he was a young guy, he knew the ropes, he knew the constraints of the budget and he was already in the club and therefore not an expensive booking,” Cosgrove said, speaking on the BBC's Scottish Football Podcast.

“That was the motivation of it and he began this lengthy journey of identifying players that he thought could do a job for us against the backdrop of us having lost a generation of players: Ali McCann, Jason Kerr, Shaun Rooney, who were at the core of the great double winning team.

“In a way it was a ferociously difficult job that they were doing but I suspect maybe the job was too difficult for Steven. There were too many things going on and to some extent experience would be what’s probably required next."

Cosgrove also gave his thoughts on who the club might turn to next, with Livingston boss David Martindale one of several names linked.

“I’m not really a great fan of looking at managers that have been in similar problems to us. For example Livingston are hardly setting the world on fire, so people talking about David Martindale, I’m less convinced.

“There’s a lot of people who want to go with a laptop manager, we’ve got a group of fans who are very much about analysis, statistics and data and to some extent they want a modern manager that has those skills.

“We’ve seen recently, not least at Rangers and at Hibernian, those young managers full of PowerPoint excellence can be duds.

“It’s quite a difficult one. The only thing I would say is whoever gets appointed will be appointed through process.

"It will be someone that will be affordable to the club, someone that will be tasked with working with what he’s got, maybe an extra couple of quid to make signings in the January window, but it’ll not be somebody who’s given carte blanche that’s for sure.”

Steven MacLeanImage source, SNS

Related topics