McNulty Q&A: Assessing the win over Man City

Phil McNulty banner
  • Published

Aaron H: What is your opinion on the two tackles made by Mateo Kovacic against Arsenal? Should he have been sent off?

McNulty: In my opinion, Kovacic should have been sent off. No question.

The first one on Martin Odegaard was very close to a red card and once he had committed another poor challenge on Declan Rice right after after I was amazed referee Michael Oliver did not send him off. I was equally surprised Pep Guardiola sent Kovacic out for the second half because he could not risk another foul.

Of course, unlike the fiasco of Spurs against Liverpool, this was a subjective decision made by Oliver but, to most observers, Kovacic should have gone. At least Gabriel Martinelli’s winner meant VAR wasn’t the big talking point again.

Hit 'Follow' at the top of this page and if you are using the BBC Sport app, tap the bell icon to get Arsenal news and analysis sent straight to you

Mateo Kovacic tackles Declan RiceImage source, Getty Images

@win_n10: Is this truly an open title race?

McNulty: Well it’s certainly been an encouraging week for those hoping for something other than a stroll from this season’s title race.

Manchester City are still my tip for the title, as per pre-season predictions, but Wolves and Arsenal have shown they are beatable and Pep Guardiola’s side are short of their best. They are certainly missing Kevin de Bruyne and missed the suspended Rodri against Arsenal.

Arsenal’s win may well prove to be hugely significant because they will want to go one better than last season and that win - their first in 16 league games against City - could turn out to be a massive psychological breakthrough.

Joe: What do you make of Arteta's decision to drop Ramsdale after such a good season last year?

Phil: Hi Joe. I was really surprised as I thought Aaron Ramsdale did very well last season but it is obvious Mikel Arteta has seen something he can improve on and David Raya, in his opinion, provides it.

It is clear from this team selection and all the messages that Raya is now Arsenal’s first choice but it did seem harsh to me.

Raya has not yet convinced me he is a huge upgrade on Ramsdale. He was very mixed with the ball at his feet against Manchester City, twice almost getting caught on his line by Julian Alvarez, but did improve as the game went on.

Don’t get me wrong. Raya is a fine keeper but still think it was pretty tough on Ramsdale.

BBC chief football writer Phil McNulty is taking questions from supporters on all things Premier Leaguein our live page here

Related topics