Why does Euro success not translate to Scotland?

- Published
BBC Sport Scotland's Andy Burke has been answering some of your Scottish rugby questions.
VIPip asked: Edinburgh and Glasgow showed some amount of mental resilience and no soft underbelly to win against Toulon and Sale Sharks respectively. Why can't these same players, especially in the forwards, not do that for Scotland?
Andy answered: Well the first thing to say, and it's a fairly obvious point, is Test rugby is a significant step up even from the Champions Cup. The pressure and intensity are a different level.
These were two brilliant results for Glasgow and Edinburgh, make no mistake about it, but round one of the Champions Cup compared with the knockout stages – far less Test rugby – are two different beasts.
I do think it all comes back to psychology. Scottish players have proved they can go toe to toe with the best sides for spells in matches and even produce the odd victory, but when it comes to the absolute crunch of a must-win game – whether that be latter stages of the Champions Cup or in Six Nations and World Cups – they have generally been found wanting.
Glasgow's run to the URC title in 2024 was the exception rather than the rule.
The best sides save their best for the biggest games and most find another gear when the big prizes are in sight. Scotland need to find that next level if they are to compete for trophies.
RDW asked: Edinburgh have a really strong pack but there's no doubt the backs need significant improvement, albeit they also have some talented youngsters in the squad. Is it time to push the boat out to land a high value half-back or centre if we can, or stick with the youth?
Andy answered: Edinburgh's midfield has long been a problem area. They have never quite been able to find settled combinations between 10-12 and 12-13, which pretty much all the top teams possess.
Ross Thompson and Ben Healy have both, for a variety of reasons, failed to make the 10 jersey their own, but I thought Cammy Scott's performance against Toulon was very impressive. He should get a run at stand-off to see if he's the man to get this backline ticking.
A proper lynchpin at 12 would be a priority for me. A playmaker who can also make inroads at the gainline would be invaluable.
The hope was Mosese Tuipulotu would be that figure, much like his brother is for Glasgow. He has a slowish start to his Edinburgh career and unfortunately injury has robbed him of the chance to kick on.
Hopefully he can return and take his game to another level, but 12 is definitely a position to look at when it comes to new recruits.