Is it a poor year for UK festival headliners?

  • Published
Glastonbury headliners
BySinead Garvan
Newsbeat music reporter

Some of the biggest bands in the world are headlining UK festivals this year.

For months though, there has been criticism of the artists topping the bill across the board.

It is not the first time certain big festivals have come under fire, but this year there seems to be more criticism.

At a recent music conference, an executive from a live events company said it was a "poor year for headliners".

Melvin Benn runs Festival Republic which puts on Latitude and Reading/Leeds, among others.

He told Newsbeat: "Here at Latitude we've got the best line-up we've ever had.

"Interestingly enough, we've got three headliners that have never headlined a UK festival before. Maybe I've taken a risk others weren't willing to take."

Latitude Festival headliners
Image caption,

Two Door Cinema Club, Damon Albarn and The Black Keys headline Latitude Festival

He also admitted, no matter what your wish list is, availability is a big player in who you can get to perform.

"It depends hugely on the touring schedules and I think people underestimate how important it is.

"They can travel everywhere but the demand on their time is significant."

Jamie MacColl from Bombay Bicycle Club is also unimpressed with the line-ups on offer this year.

"I think it's pretty poor, people aren't very ambitious with who they book, it's the same bands every year," he said.

"I've lost count of how many festivals with either the Black Keys or Arctic Monkeys headlining.

"Even at somewhere like Glastonbury, I thought after they booked Jay Z there would be more leftfield bookings but it's quite conservative."

Reading and Leeds festival headliners
Image caption,

Queens of The Stone Age, Arctic Monkeys and Blink 182 headline Reading and Leeds Festivals

The announcement of Metallica headlining on Saturday night at Worthy Farm caused quite a stir.

Alex Turner described it as an "out there" choice while Jarvis Cocker said it could be a "bit abrasive" as festival-goers can be fragile.

Metallica drummer Lars Ulrich said he didn't mind the backlash.

"I enjoy the hoopla because I think it's comforting that 32 years into a career you can still stir it up a bit," he said.

"It's better that people have an opinion, even the naysayers, than they don't care."

But Metallica are an established act and one of the biggest-selling bands in the world, so it is not really that "out there" as a choice.

The question really should be, when and how do the newer artists get their chance to top the bill?

You Me At Six have a number one album and have sold out Wembley Arena.

"The industry hasn't really allowed new bands to take that pole position in the last 10 years," frontman Josh Franceschi explained.

"They keep supporting manufactured pop acts, you've got to bring in the old boys because none of the new bands are taking that beacon."

T in the Park festival
Image caption,

Biffy Clyro, Calvin Harris and Arctic Monkeys headline T in the Park festival

Smaller festivals like Wilderness, Secret Garden Party and Field Day are giving the headline opportunity to younger acts.

This year, Field Day gave Metronomy their first ever UK headline slot.

"It's important to me in the sense that we've worked with Metronomy for years so there's a sort of history there," said festival organiser Tom Baker.

"It's an important moment for a band like that. They've played Field Day before a couple of years back and then they come and close the event.

"And if they can use that to further their career, I think it is important for sure."

Once an act has headlined a festival, then there is always the possibility of other organisers seeing them in that light.

Latitude gave Foals their first UK headline slot last year and this September they are topping the bill at Bestival.

Follow us @BBCNewsbeat, external on Twitter and @Radio1Newsbeat, external on YouTube

Related internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.